What the Long-Term Evidence Shows
A hip or knee replacement is meant to last for many years, and for most people it does. Here is what the best national registry evidence actually shows, from Mr Paddy Subramanian.
A hip or knee replacement is one of the most reliable operations in modern medicine, and the single question patients ask most is how long it will last. This guide sets out what the largest long-term studies show, what makes a replacement last longer or wear out sooner, and what happens in the small number of cases where one needs replacing. It is general information, not a substitute for the advice Mr Subramanian gives you about your own joint.
A modern total hip replacement is one of the most successful and durable operations there is. The most recent evidence, using National Joint Registry and global registry data, projects that around nine in ten modern total hip replacements are still working at 25 years, and close to that at 30 years. The National Joint Registry notes that, with today's implants, a hip replacement can be expected to last the rest of their life for most patients over about 70. An older figure of around 58 per cent, still widely quoted, reflects implants fitted decades ago. These numbers describe large groups of patients rather than a guarantee for any one person.
Knee replacements are similarly long-lasting. A large registry study found that 82.3% of total knee replacements were still working at 25 years, with partial (unicompartmental) replacements at 69.8%. As with hips, these numbers reflect older implants, so a knee replaced today may last longer still.
A replacement wears gradually over many years rather than failing suddenly. It tends to last longest when you keep to a healthy weight, stay active without repeated high-impact loading, and when the replacement was fitted accurately with a well-chosen, registry-proven implant. Surgical accuracy matters, which is why Mr Subramanian uses robotic assistance where it adds precision. Infection, a fall, or a replacement that was not well aligned can shorten its working life.
To an extent, yes. A replacement has a finite working life, and the more it is loaded over the years, the sooner it may eventually need attention. That is why younger and very active patients are counselled about the chance of a revision later in life, and why the timing of surgery and the choice of implant are discussed carefully. For most people the gain in pain-free movement far outweighs this, and the decision is always made together.
Yes. When a replacement eventually loosens, wears or fails, it can be revised, an operation that replaces the worn implant. Revision hip and revision knee surgery is more complex than the first operation and benefits from a surgeon who performs it regularly. It is a particular interest of Mr Subramanian's practice, with more than 260 hip and knee revision procedures recorded on the National Joint Registry under his care.
Using today's implants, the most recent registry evidence projects that around nine in ten modern total hip replacements are still working at 25 years. For many patients over about 70, a hip replacement can be expected to last the rest of their life. The older 58 per cent figure often quoted comes from implants fitted decades ago.
About 82% of total knee replacements are still in place at 25 years, and partial (unicompartmental) replacements around 70%. Modern implants are expected to last at least as long.
Modern hip and knee implants, whether metal, ceramic or hard-wearing plastic, are all designed for long-term durability, and the registry figures cover the implants in common use today. Mr Subramanian chooses a registry-proven implant to suit your age, activity and anatomy rather than one material for everyone.
It can be revised in a further operation that replaces the worn implant. This is more complex than the first replacement and is a particular interest of Mr Subramanian's practice.
Most people never do. Whether a revision becomes necessary depends on your age at surgery, how active you are and how the implant wears, and it is something we discuss with you honestly.
Living with hip or knee pain does not have to be permanent. Book a consultation and find out exactly what is wrong, what your options are, and what life could look like without the pain.